James Leung
ENG 11000-B - Freshman Composition Section
42187
2/18/15
An Outsider Among Friends
Only now as a college
freshman, I have decided on learning Chinese.
Although the first language I ever spoke was Cantonese, the only
language I became fluent in was English.
Most Chinese American friends I had grew up learning both Chinese and
English, but at a young age I rejected Chinese.
As I got older, I was given more and more reasons why to know solely
English. I was pretty good at English in school and had no struggles learning
it. It wasn't until around my senior year of high school, that I gained the
desire to learn Chinese myself.
I lived in two
households during my childhood, in my grandparents' large home in Staten Island
and in my parents' cramped apartment in Chinatown. I was around four years old, and I loved it
whenever my mom popped in VHS tapes of Chinese cartoons for me to watch. Through watching these tapes all the time I
slowly learned basic phrases of Chinese. However, the limited amount of tapes
we had bored me and I stopped watching them. That was when my mom began to buy American
VHS tapes for me, causing me to fall in love with Blue's Clues, Power Rangers,
and Digimon. Religiously after Pre-K
class, I would go home and watch as much as a I could of the new tapes my mom
got me. Quickly my English became far
superior to my ability to speak Chinese.
It was kindergarten when
I began distancing myself from Chinese completely. I remember I was talking to my tablemates one
day as our teacher went around to check everyone's homework. The room was filled with kids laughing until
our teacher arrived at a kid that didn't do his homework. All the kids noticed and the room entered a
dead silence. After our teacher asked
why, with all eyes on him, he replied that his parents told him to do his
Chinese school homework instead. Sternly
our teacher told him that regular school came first to Chinese school. While this message was directed to him, at
the time I felt that message was directed to all of us as well. Later at home, I told my mom about what
happened and, wanting the best for my education, she explained further why
regular school was more important than Chinese school. That day instilled the
idea into my head that compared to English, Chinese was obsolete and I would be
better off not learning it. Thereafter
whenever my grandparents nagged me about enrolling into Chinese school, I
refused for I had rejected Chinese from my life.
I went through the rest
of elementary school and middle school with the belief that Chinese was
useless, but during high school my beliefs started to changed. Freshman year of high school I was given the
choice of taking Chinese or Spanish for my language class. Since I despised Spanish with a passion in
middle school, the obvious choice was Chinese.
However, according to the school, freshmen could not take both geometry
and Chinese, so I had to choose between those two. Due to me wanting to be ahead in my math
courses, I chose geometry and ended up taking Spanish. While it was easy for me to pick geometry, I
did get somewhat of a rebellious attitude towards the school practically
forcing me to drop Chinese. Later in my
junior year I heard that the school changed their policy and now allowed
Chinese and geometry to be taken simultaneously which frustrated me
deeply. This frustration was a small
spark to my gain of interest in Chinese.
I began to get the idea in my head of "Why can't I?", but
never acted on it in high school.
What catapulted my desire
to learn Chinese was the alienation I felt being among my friends who all spoke
fluent Chinese. From junior to senior
year, the amount of Chinese friends that I had and the time that I spent with
them grew. Every moment I spent with
them I loved, except for those moments that displayed me as the only one who
was illiterate in Chinese. There would
be times when some of my friends would say jokes with a Chinese phrase or even
the entire joke would be in Chinese and I would be the only one not laughing. Not laughing because I had no idea what was
said. My rejection of the Chinese
language was no more and instead I desired to learn it. The most embarrassing showcasing of my
ignorance happened in January of this year. Six of my friends, all being fluent
in Chinese, came over to my apartment to hang out. It was really cramped inside my living room
but we were glad not to be outside with the torrential rain. After playing the party game Werewolves with
each other for hours, eventually we got hungry and wanted to order Chinese
food. Since it was my house my friends
made me make the order. The problem was
the person on the other side of the phone only spoke Chinese. Flustered, I asked the man on the phone to
repeat what he said but in English.
Again came the same words I could not understand. Embarrassingly I handed the phone to one of
my friends and had him make the order.
Throughout most my life
I considered Chinese to be useless but I, lacking the ability to speak Chinese,
ended up being useless. The feeling
of having no clue what your friends or
the people around are saying, really got to me that day in January. I felt like a kid excluded from a special
club or brotherhood just because I did not know the language that most the
people in my lives did. That is why
recently I decided to take up Chinese this summer and hopefully learn what I
had neglected since childhood. Learning
Chinese will be really difficult since I'm doing it late and on my own. To do so I will be using language teaching programs,
watching Chinese television shows, and attempt to talk to friends or family
members in Chinese. This process will
help me with my major too, because computer science has many coding languages that
I will need to learn. I've never had to
gone through the challenges of learning an unknown language, so the experience I
gain through the process of learning Chinese will be very helpful.
After successfully being
able to coherently speak and understand Chinese I will be able to communicate with
relatives better instead of the "Chinglish" I use with them now. Normally
a conversation with my grandparents lasts a long and awkward five minutes, but acquiring
Chinese will change that completely and better my relationship with them. My relationship with them is not bad by any means
but could be improved vastly. Once I get through the struggle of learning Chinese,
the struggle of communicating with family members will be gone as well. Lastly, the cold sense of exclusion from my friends
that urged me to learn Chinese, will also cease to exist.
After writing this literacy narrative, not learning Chinese throughout my life became more than simply because I was to lazy. Thinking about the topic more and dwelling delving deeper into my memories, helped me see why I neglected Chinese and who influenced my decisions. My biggest take away from writing my literacy narrative was realizing how sensitive I am to the feeling of exclusion or need of inclusion by friends. My connections with friends was so precious to me that I did not want to be left out just because I could not speak Chinese. Writing this literacy narrative was very insightful and gave me a sense of nostalgia when remembering some of the things from my childhood. I thought it was interesting to examine the people or things that helped shape my life just through language.
ReplyDeleteSolid intro, makes me want to know more about why you didn't become fluent in Cantonese and why it took you until just recently to try learning it again. I like the example of watching cartoons as a way of literacy acquisition because I remember myself loving to watch Avatar the Last Air Bender even though I didn't understand it yet. I can also relate to how you were with your friends and you didn't understand the jokes because that happened to me to when I didn't know English yet and it was very frustrating at times. I like how you said that you were thought that knowing Chinese is useless but then you ended up feeling useless for not knowing it. Great story overall and I hope you will be able to finally master Chinese.
ReplyDeleteYour narrative was very well thought out and organized. I was engaged by your narrative because I am a Chinese American myself and I was able to relate to your narrative a bit more because of my cultural background. Your narrative was very detailed and vivid. I felt as if I was peering into your own childhood, seeing you sit on the floor watching American cartoons. Most important of all, the structure of your essay was outstanding. The transition of your thoughts as you grow up, flowed through the narrative and I was able to understand your point of view completely. It was a great story and good luck on learning Chinese in the future.
ReplyDeleteI thoroughly enjoyed reading your story. I am Hispanic and can relate in some aspects of your narrative. Sometimes when you are a minority we tend to compensate to fit in society, or what we sometimes believe society wants us to be. As we grow older and wiser we realize that what society believes doesn't really apply anymore. In closing, I am glad that you are learning the Cantonese language and wish you the best on your journey.
ReplyDeleteSean @ Excel Translations