Wednesday, March 4, 2015

Summary & Response - Maria Boleaga

Maria L. Boleaga
English 110
March 4, 2015
Union is equal to one
In his speech  "A More Perfect Union," published in 2008 senator Barack Obama  addresses the topic of people uniting to make some changes in our society and argues that  we should not let children of the 21st century inherit our problems. We should help them pick up the pace of our community about race  and other kind of problems that is affecting our society. Barack Obama asserts many things that can unite the society such as stopping racism and being able to unite as one, he implies that we should not make the same mistakes we did years ago. He supports this claim by starting of  with the unfinished Declaration of Independence, it was both a good and bad about this new document; meaning that once  the Declaration of Independence was made people could have their liberty and justice, but "everyone" did not include other races, such as the Black race. This document  was the cause of slavery because since it was never mentioned that Black people could also have their liberty and justice, slave owners continued the trade of slavery. Then he talks about how till this day racism still exist;  racism shouldn't be a problem anymore. Finally he gives an example of a White woman named Ashley Baia who united people that had similar problems like hers, example losing health care insurance. This is where it all begins if our society wants change by uniting people no matter what race especially the children of today, we should help them understand the problems of today and how it should be changed. Obama's audience to his speech goes to the new generation and to people that had gone through these experiences to show the new generation that history should not repeat itself.
Obama's purpose is to unite our society in order to stop racism no matter if you're Black, White, Hispanic, Asian or Native American we should help one another given like the example Ashley's story. Using Ashley's story helps support his claim because he is describing how change can happen in our society  if only we unite. Obama wants us to understand that issues such as racism continues and we must not repeat these times again. In order for this change to happen we must unite "For we have a choice in this country. We can accept a politics that breeds division, and conflict, and cynicism. We can tackle race only as spectacle". This was a great quote said in his speech because he is telling our society that there can be change.  Barack Obama establishes a formal and a matter of fact tone with his audience of this speech and others interested in the topic on race. He talks about how important it is but it should not be an issue that is always put to aside.
When I began reading Obama's speech, my reactions to this was that it was interested because what got my attention was that he started off his speech with the Declaration of Independence; of how this document changed our society and the reactions that it had to people when this documents was made. Obama held his speech well focused, he started off with the past and finished his speech with the present and I think that's what holds a good and consistent speech because he does not go off topic. Reading Barack Obama's speech made me want to get off  my seat and express "We are the change, we are the ones that can only make a difference to our society, we are ONE". Most people would agree with  Obama's speech because instead of having race become an issue, we should be a union. We should not let the Congress, Government and Politics corrupt our society, if we want change we must build a union and work together as a team like Barack Obama said in his speech "This union may never be perfect, but generation after generation has shown that it can always be perfected". Perfection can always start of by uniting people; each generation can teach us something new so we can’t repeat history again.

Tuesday, March 3, 2015

Summary & Response - Winnie Ngo


Winnie Ngo
English 110
4 March

Television: Apparently the Cause of Family Problems
Marie Winn, an author and a translator of Czech writers, in her excerpt, “Television: The Plug-In Drug,” claims that television has had negative effects on families in America. Marie Winn describes how the families’ schedules become regimented, the families no longer spend unique quality times together, and children’s needs are not met while parents enjoy the undemanding lifestyle. She supports her claims by describing these current family situations and adding other people’s personal experiences or thoughts. As families’ tight schedules are set, life has become mechanized and less enjoyable. Not only does television reduce the quality time family members spend bonding with each other, but the case of allowing the television to entertain also causes the parents to neglect the children’s needs for growth and development.  Her purpose is to bring to her readers’ attention the damaging effects of television on the development and maintenance of the relationships that hold families together to raise awareness of what she considers a damaging and rapidly growing issue. Because of the author’s nostalgic and informative tone, her writing appears to target people who are concerned about unhealthy family relationships.
When I first read Marie Winn’s “Television: The Plug-in Drug” I was expecting it to be about the addiction of television, but it turned out to be about the impact of television on family relationships. While reading Winn’s work, I understand where she is coming from but I could not fully agree with her argument. I felt that her supporting details to her claims weren’t very effective because it revolved around a single idea that television stops families from communicating with each other. I believe that there are many other stronger factors that prevent communication such as the parents’ lack a time due to work. As a result, I didn’t feel convinced that television is a strong cause of the weakening bond between family members. After listening to other people’s thoughts in class, it was clear that I wasn’t the only one who felt that Winn did not provide strong enough supporting details to prove her point.
I felt that many of her statements were quite repetitive and she kept suggesting that the lack of those quality times families had from previous times is the center of the problem.  She mostly illustrated how television has created the lack of interactive experiences between the family members; families no longer enjoy specific kinds of jokes, songs, games and other activities together that make each family unique. I understand that television has certainly changed the way time is spent among family members, but I believe that television do provide that common enjoyment that brings them together. From my personal experience, right after watching television, my family would spend time talking about what we had just watched or topics related to it. Even if televisions didn’t serve a healthy purpose for family bonding it does not mean that it is the main problem for communication and bonding.  Parents and children living in today’s society do lack the time to spend with each other for multiple reasons. One of them could be the struggle to keep up societies growing standards; everyone is expected to obtain a college degree, get a good career, and maintain a stable social status.
Without the use of statistics or significant studies it's hard to say that television is the root of the problems she states. The quotes from each individual she provided were nice to have, but they weren’t all that reliable or powerful enough to strengthen her argument because not everyone has the same experience. She even states at the end that television isn’t aren’t the only factor for the decline in family life, which makes it even more difficult for me to agree with her claims.
Although I don’t completely agree with Marie Winn’s argument there were some ideas that did catch my attention. I found the part where she mentions the study that demonstrated the importance of eye-to-eye contact for relationships because I personally feel that I have a problems looking straight into other people eyes once in a while and I didn’t know the reason for it.

Marie Winn’s argument is understandable because she had grown up in a very different society, but it difficult to apply her ideal family life to the current day social structure.

Summary and Response - James Leung

James Leung
ENG 11000-B FC
March 4, 2015
Kapitalism for Kids
            In his article "Kid Kustomers", investigative journalist an writer Eric Schlosser addresses the topic of marketing being directed towards kids and argues that advertisements for kids have grown enormously in the past two decades due to its effectiveness to sell product and the lack of regulation.  He supports his claim by supplying evidence of how influential child mascots in advertisements are, then demonstrating the profitability of child clubs in establishments such as Burger King, and finally explaining the FTC's rejected ban on child advertising through television.  Schlosser's purpose is to expose the large trend in marketing towards children in order to prevent companies profiting off of the immature minds of kids absorbing the information from the ads.  Because of his informative tone, it seems as he writes for an audience of readers ignorant to the large marketing toward kids and of readers that are parents.
            I also believe that child marketing has become widespread due to its ability to increase sales and the lack of regulation on it.  Children are so impressionable that when they see something that peeks even a bit of interest in an advertisement, the next moment they are asking their parents to buy it for them.  Television is plagued by advertisements that appeal to children.  As Schlosser mentioned, Youth Market System Consulting has a division specifically dedicated to creating mascots for children that match their child target age group.  Children can remember an advertising mascot for their entire lives, always having the brand of the advertiser in the back of the minds.  As a child I would always tell my parents to buy me Fruity Pebbles cereal.  The thing is I barely ate the cereal because I didn't even eat breakfast.  The reason I constantly nagged my parents at the grocery store to buy the cereal was that I loved the Flintstones commercials that were advertising them all the time.  A product can be completely useless to a child but they can still want it if marketed to them with a proper mascot.
            Additionally, I agree that the results that come from children's clubs are extremely profitable.  Schlosser argues that children's clubs are great for collecting consumer data from the children and Kids love joining clubs because it gives them a sense of exclusiveness and friendship.  The incentive of being part of a group lures kids in and ends up trapping parents who have to pay for whatever the establishment of the club has to offer.  Being part of a club also means that the child will be committed to going back to the club consistently, resulting in a regularly attending customer.
            Schlosser also discusses the FTC's proposed ban on child ads and how it was eventually turned down.  The Federal Trade Commission decided to take action and proposed a ban on child ads. The proposal was lead by the head of the FTC, Michael Pertschuk, and was supported by several groups.  However, there were also many groups that did not seem to like the ban as much.  The opposing groups lobbied Congress aiming to stop any bans on child ads.  They even ended up suing Pertschuk so that he wouldn't be able to attend any FTC meetings about the proposal.  As you can tell from the abundance of child ads on television now, the ban was rejected.  I can't believe how far the companies who profit from child marketing are willing to go to protect their sales.  How is it fair for the FTC to make a decision when the head of the FTC cannot even attend the meetings pertaining to the issue.  Children aren't mature enough to make their own decisions and on top of that, the supporters for child advertisement took away the voice of the people trying to defend the children.

            The growth of child advertisements overall is not very surprising.  For instance, you have toy companies left and right telling kids to buy the hottest toy.  Most of the time it's not even just one toy, it's usually many toys at once and the advertisements are practically shoving down children's throats the idea of having to "collect them all".  The fact that advertisers continue to use this business method illustrates that the method is working and sales are going up.  Lastly, as long as child marketing is profitable and unrestricted, child ads will continue to grow abundantly. 

On the Dangers of Staring Too Long Into the Abyss


John Droescher                                             
English 11000
04 Mar 2015
On the Dangers of Gazing Too Long Into the Abyss.
               Chock full of data and factoids, Eric Schlosser’s article “Kid Kustomers” is a piece of rhetorical genius. Author of Fast Food America, Schlosser seems to be the perfect journalist to lead the charge against another group of large predatory Corporations. And he does so in this article vehemently.
               Beginning with a nostalgic look at the dearth of children-specific advertising of yesteryear, Schlosser lays the groundwork for his argument against Corporate exploitation of children. Sometime in the 1980s, according to Schlosser, increasingly busy parents began spending on their children in greater amounts attempting to alleviate the guilt they were feeling from spending less time with their children. Marketing and advertising firms began picking up on this and increasingly targeted their clients’ campaigns to take advantage of this rising market.
               Around the same time, these advertising and marketing companies increased research into the subtleties of the manner in which consumers received and processed advertisements. Much of this research was directed toward children and the possibility of creating lifelong brand loyalty. Additionally, marketing and advertising companies began developing new methods of collecting, collating, and processing data. As a result, children were increasingly subjected to advertising campaigns imperceptible to their developing psyches.
               Examples of these campaigns include kids clubs which were not only utilized as advertising platforms but also to collect data from children who were unaware of the privacy concerns involved. In response, the United States Congress passed a law restricting these predatory campaigns. These data mining campaigns were combined with dream research to develop children’s programs and advertisements designed to appeal directly to young and impressionable minds.
               Attempts to combat this exploitation of impressionable young psyches have been overwhelmingly unsuccessful due to the influence of Corporate interests on both regulatory bodies and the US Congress. The only real success in the campaign to combat predatory advertising has been the forced abandonment of the Joe Camel mascot and the use of a portion of cigarette profits to actively educate the public of the dangers of smoking.
               Premised on the “won’t someone think of the children” canard, Schlosser’s article is full of appeals to emotion. While he presents relevant data to show that children are increasingly being targeted by ad campaigns designed to create a lifetime of brand loyalty, at no time does he present data that this is a specifically bad thing. There is no study backing the assertion that creating brand loyalty negatively impacts the lives of these children, nor the young adults, nor even older generations who have been subjected to these ever increasingly specifically targeted ad campaigns.
               In fact, the only negative to be found is based upon the idea that manipulation of a person’s mind is inherently immoral, and manipulation of a child’s mind is even more so. Which is, in many respects, patently ridiculous. Every day interactions between individuals often involve subtle manipulations. Despite adults being heavily susceptible to manipulation, the increasingly partisanized, rapidly growing following of the Fox News Channel exists as an example, there is no outcry regarding said manipulations. Schlosser’s argument boils down to the tired, old: “Won’t someone think of the children?” canard which is nothing more than a fallacious appeal to emotion.
               Schlosser does deserve much credit, however. As a journalist and an author he has mastered the art of persuasion. Ironically, perhaps, given that his persuasion relies on similar tricks to those marketing and advertising companies use to promote their own goods, and agendas, at the expense of their competitors. Despite offering copious data and arguments in support of his position, virtually no valid counterpoints are presented, nor is any raw data that could be interpreted to detract from his argument presented in this article. So masterfully is this manipulation penned that even the above average reader is persuaded by the argument until these machinations are expressly pointed out. Schlosser reveals he has ignored Nietzche’s warning regarding gazing too long into the abyss and so has become a monster himself.

Summary and Response Essay - Pnina Grossman

TV & Reefer Madness

            In her article, Television: the Plug in Drug, journalist Marie Winn argues that the presence and prevalence of television in modern society has led to the decay of family life. To support her claim, Winn relies mostly on her conjecture and analysis, supported with anecdotal evidence from teachers, therapists and parents. Her purpose is to make people aware of the powerful influence that television can have on the family dynamic in order to allow them to take control of this influence and their own family dynamic. As such, the author uses an authoritative tone to instruct the audience of parents and other adult authority figures that dealing with this problem should be a priority.
            The tone in this paper is the first thing that brings the reader to ask – what expertise and authority does Winn have that enables her to define the ideal family dynamic and how does she know that television is disrupting it? Both questions don’t find easy answers within the piece, which makes the cautious reader uneasy in accepting Winn’s claims. Winn seems to have some ideal image of a perfect family dynamic in her mind, but she does not enlighten the reader as to what that perfect dynamic is besides for noting that television has disrupted family rituals. Additionally, Winn mentions that some other factors that have previously contributed to “the decline of family life in America” are “the rising divorce rate, the increase in the number of working mothers, the trends towards people moving far away from home, [and] the breakdown of neighborhoods and communities.” While this also hints at what Winn’s idea of a perfect family dynamic entails, the factors included show that Winn’s idea of a family does not include many modern, and happy, modern families who might have working mothers or find themselves spanning larger distances then just the area around the patriarch and matriarch’s house.
            Even with an idea of Winn’s ideal family, it is unclear that television is disrupting the dynamic of this family on a large scale, as Winn claims it is. The evidence Winn brings to support her claims is almost entirely anecdotal: a teacher talking about a mother who does not spend time with her daughter because of television, a therapist describing a family where the problems are masked by television, and a young woman talking about how her family rituals disappeared due to television. On an individual level, these stories might be unpleasant, but Winn does not produce statistics or expert opinions to prove that these stories are the rule and not the exception. Furthermore, Winn seems to conflate a family that owns a television with a family that spends all of their free time watching television, once again, without bringing in statistics to back up this claim.

            Though the reader of this essay might instinctively agree with Winn’s position on television coming in to the article, the judgmental tone of the piece and its lack of proof make it hard for the reader to leave the piece agreeing with Winn. Most readers are likely to feel defensive when encountering Winn’s simultaneously vague yet narrow definition of what a good family dynamic consists of, which make them less likely to want to be convinced by her argument. Had Winn marshalled statistics to support her claim, the reader would have had no choice but to agree with it, despite whatever personal feelings the reader had, but left supported only by anecdotal evidence, Winn’s piece is more likely to make people disagree with her claim than agree with it.